Investment, not ownership, is the issue for Britain’s railways - FT中文网
登录×
电子邮件/用户名
密码
记住我
请输入邮箱和密码进行绑定操作:
请输入手机号码,通过短信验证(目前仅支持中国大陆地区的手机号):
请您阅读我们的用户注册协议隐私权保护政策,点击下方按钮即视为您接受。
基建投资

Investment, not ownership, is the issue for Britain’s railways

Nationalising train operators is no guarantee of better performance
00:00

{"text":[[{"start":10.15,"text":"The new UK government’s plans to nationalise rail services are thundering down the parliamentary tracks faster than most trains on the country’s rickety rail network. "},{"start":18.692,"text":"They add up to a major reversal of one of the flagship Conservative privatisations of the 1980s and 1990s. "},{"start":24.909,"text":"The commitment of Sir Keir Starmer’s Labour to “move fast and fix things” is commendable; fixing the railways is important not just for passengers but to boost economic growth. "},{"start":33.639,"text":"But in prioritising ownership it is focusing on the wrong issue. "}],[{"start":37.59,"text":"A bill set for a lightning third reading on Tuesday will return franchised passenger rail services to public hands when existing contracts end or reach a breakpoint — which at least means this renationalisation has little upfront cost. "},{"start":49.607,"text":"The government says it will produce a more centralised network, under the “directing mind” of a still-to-be-created arms-length body, Great British Railways. "},{"start":57.512,"text":"It touts the potential to cut costs by removing duplicative bureaucracy, and to simplify the unpopular maze of ticketing. "}],[{"start":65.07000000000001,"text":"The danger, though, is that as with British Rail in the 1970s, public ownership will mean poor management and cost control, and empower rail unions with which Labour has just expensively settled long-running pay disputes. "},{"start":77.43700000000001,"text":"Recent experience shows state control does not guarantee better service. "},{"start":81.40400000000001,"text":"Ask long-suffering passengers of Northern Rail, one of four previously franchised services already taken back by the state. "}],[{"start":89.08000000000001,"text":"The flawed franchising system created distorted incentives; several large franchises failed after overpromising on revenues. "},{"start":96.40900000000002,"text":"But the Conservative government committed in 2021 to shift to passenger service contracts with private companies, which pay a fee for providing tightly specified services with penalties for failures to meet targets. "},{"start":107.27700000000002,"text":"This was a sensible concept that avoided full nationalisation. "},{"start":110.85700000000001,"text":"Several countries, including Germany and Sweden, use service contracts on some services. "},{"start":116.12400000000001,"text":"In Japan’s famously reliable rail network, the private sector takes the lead on almost all routes, though with a very different structure to Britain’s. "}],[{"start":124.13000000000001,"text":"With about half of cancellations blamed on infrastructure owners, the biggest problem dogging Britain’s railways is not ownership of operators but constrained and crumbling capacity. "},{"start":133.447,"text":"This follows years of inconsistent and inadequate government-led investment in rail infrastructure, most of which was returned to public hands under Network Rail in 2002. "},{"start":142.352,"text":"Sustained higher investment in tracks is vital — but Labour, though it has promised a more detailed rail reform bill in due course, has so far said little on this subject. "}],[{"start":152.43,"text":"The need is all the greater after then prime minister Rishi Sunak last year cancelled the remaining northern leg of HS2, the high-speed project from London originally to Manchester and Leeds. "},{"start":162.297,"text":"Though costs had ballooned, HS2 promised new capacity as much as speed. "},{"start":166.80200000000002,"text":"The government must urgently find other ways to ease congestion on the West Coast main line, where commuter and intercity services share tracks in places, and which is vital for the net zero priority of shifting freight from roads to rail. "},{"start":178.44400000000002,"text":"It should study a plan from city mayors and engineering firms for a cheaper, privately funded line along HS2’s axed Birmingham-Manchester route. "}],[{"start":187.38,"text":"It would also be helpful for the government to clarify its view of Northern Powerhouse Rail, the proposed east-west line connecting northern English cities that is central to revitalising services. "},{"start":197.272,"text":"And it should draw up coherent plans for redirecting funds no longer being spent on HS2 to other projects. "}],[{"start":204.16,"text":"In doing so, Labour should heed the advice of a policy review it commissioned, and seek private funding too. "},{"start":210.402,"text":"The report led by former Siemens UK boss Juergen Maier recommended new partnerships, akin to those often used in Europe and Asia, involving “blended finance” — with the private sector taking on delivery and recouping a return later. "},{"start":222.482,"text":"In revitalising rail, Britain’s new government would be wise to create room for more private sector investment and involvement, not less. "}],[{"start":229.57,"text":""}]],"url":"https://creatives.ftmailbox.cn/album/169995-1725420339.mp3"}

版权声明:本文版权归FT中文网所有,未经允许任何单位或个人不得转载,复制或以任何其他方式使用本文全部或部分,侵权必究。

英国生物技术公司新药降低量身定制式癌症疗法副作用

Autolus用于治疗急性淋巴细胞白血病的新型Car-T细胞疗法在美国获批,该疗法与癌细胞结合所需时间更短,因此副作用更小。

前保守党财政大臣告诫工党现任勿看衰英国前景

杰里米•亨特表示,英国在关键增长领域表现强劲,应该停止贬低自己。

Lex专栏:游戏机制造商在低迷市场中表现强劲

虽然游戏机老化通常意味着游戏公司收入持续下降,但多年未推出新产品的索尼和任天堂等游戏公司仍表现强劲。

为年度展望报告辩护

巴克兰:定期回顾投资框架以及进行经济和市场展望是一项良好的做法。

企业长寿的奥秘为何对投资者很重要

长寿公司除了具有凝聚力、宽容度和财务保守等特征外,几乎没有什么共同点。
2天前

特朗普上台能否解决加拿大经济疲软问题?

经济学家表示,来自美国的冲击可能会使该国经济摆脱麻木状态。
设置字号×
最小
较小
默认
较大
最大
分享×